Thursday, January 2, 2014
Tuesday, December 10, 2013
Sunday, November 24, 2013
Sustainable Economics: A Response to Post by Jo Confino, Executive Editor of The Guardian on Need for a Compelling Future Vision for Sustainability to Progress
Short Piece Written in Comments Section in Response to Post by Jo Confino, Executive Editor of the Guardian, titled: "Sustainability movement will fail unless it creates a compelling future vision"
Ultimately, to survive, everything thing we do will have to
be sustainable. Everything. Throughout history, societies have faced
calamities, to which their collective response made all the difference between
survival or collapse. In most cases,
societies were unable to perceive much less respond to their inherent
unsustainable ways of living, such as the Mayans, Easter Island or the Anasazi. Their societies were based on unsustainable
and precarious systems of life support tied to the environment. In some cases, challenges have been recognized
and addressed, by perceptive and strong governments which was able to identify the problem and implement solutions.
The Japanese in the 17th century were faced with extraordinary
challenge of galloping deforestation. The
government instituted policies including using less wood for construction,
putting in more efficient heating stoves, and switched to coal from wood for
heating. Japan is currently about 70% forested. In a more recent century, the world did come together to address
CFC’s.
As seen in the United States and Europe, our carbon
emissions have come down over the past five years. Some may say we have exported our carbon
emissions to Asian countries. That can
account for some of the change, but it is also important to look at reduced
miles being driven, higher efficiency of cars, the switch to lower carbon
natural gas from coal in the United States, and the growth in renewable sources
of energy in Europe and the United States.
The US and European economies are responding to higher oil prices, which
has reduced the level of economic activity and reduced deleterious
environmental impacts. This provides a
clue to our future and solving the problem in two respects. First, economies of advanced countries do
have a higher elasticity of oil price to demand than Asian countries. Second, higher oil prices result in lower
levels of economic activity, increased efficiency, and reduced environmental
impacts. The earth is telling us to cut
back on energy, and we are. The pace of
the cut back may not be as steep a glide slope as what is sought, warranted or
needed. The implication is that we need
to do something to (1) steepen the glide slope in developed
economies; (2) reverse emissions growth in developing countries; and (3)
address severe economic and well-being inequities around the world.
Governments will play a critical and pivotal role in
turning the tide towards and accelerating the move towards a more sustainable
economy. The challenge with a capitalist
system, well established in the literature and through practice, is the
frequent absence of externalities, short time frame decision horizons, and
boundary conditions that do not address social issues such as global inequity. Nation states have a hard time being first, to take the lead on tackling large issues. The move to
address deforestation in the United States, for example, began with State and
regional initiatives to set aside parkland in the early 20th
century. We can also see more recent
examples of localization of environmental initiatives with RGGI in the
Northeast, the carbon trading initiative in California, and the implementation
of renewable energy standards in selected states, representing just a few of many excellent examples.
Ultimately, realizing a sustainable economy is in the
interest of business, governments and individuals. Without sustainable resources, economic decline, which has already begun, is inevitable, and will be inexorable and painful. Forestalling initiatives
which align our policies and investments to be consistent with a move to a
sustainable economy is not in our best interest. Having a
sustainable economy is not inconsistent with our economic interests, in
fact, ultimately it is 100% consistent. This
central tenant, that increased sustainability and increased economic well-being
are one and the same, may perhaps be that new paradigm people are looking
for. The interests of sustainability and
economics are not at cross-purposes, but are of one. Any society, any collective peoples
throughout time, who did not own and embed sustainability within their societies and cultures, did not survive.
Where does this unified theory of sustainability and
economics come from? Two
perspectives. One, mentioned earlier, is
understanding the history of societies that collapsed. The second is through understanding the
source of economic activity within our own economies, and extrapolating the
future risks our economy carries without integrating concepts of sustaining the
economy going forward.
The global economy has grown to an extraordinary degree over
the past several hundred years, tied to the level of energy entering the
economy. The level of economic activity is
explained by two things: one being the level of energetic inputs entering the
economy, and the second being the level of efficiency and productivity to which
those resources are put. Energy plus
Efficiency. If we want to grow our
economy, we have two choices, increase the amount of energy resources being
consumed, and/or increase efficiency and productivity. This is a very interesting finding, given
that we can have a growing economy with a static level of energy resources
entering the economy, as long as we improve the efficiency of resource
utilization. Second interesting finding
is that if we can economically migrate our energy systems away from
nonrenewable to renewable resources, while keeping energy use static and
improving efficiency, we can once again have a growing economy while
simultaneously reducing deleterious environmental impacts.
The cost of energy, however, plays an important role on our
level of economic activity. Higher
energy costs mean a lower level of economic activity, constrained by efficiency
improvements. If sustainable sources of
energy are a lot more expensive than non-renewable, then we will see a lowering
of economic activity. The pace of the
transition will be governed by the relative economics of the alternatives, and
the degree of incentives required to level the economic playing field, and the
pace of capital formation and its availability.
Fortunately, the economics of renewable energy are getting close to
being competitive without subsidies, with costs continuing to move down over
time with scale economies and continuous improvement. So what is the process to make this happen?
(1) Build a specific vision of where we want to be and when
in terms of sustainability. For example,
80% sustainable in 40 years. Great
detail and specificity by sector, end-use, activity, etc. is highly
recommended. (2) Identify specific performance metrics to track performance
along the way, such as proportion of renewable energy on the grid,
transportation, heating, etc. (3) Implement market incentives to encourage
private capital to make investments. Put
a price on carbon, set up carbon caps with trading, keep CAFÉ going, eliminate
subsidies on non-sustainable resources, reduce transition and market barriers
where possible, expand RPS requirements to every state, implement stretch and
zero net energy building codes in every jurisdiction in the country, implement
net metering tariffs in every state, increase CHP incentives, invest in
expanded public transit, etc. (4) Implement government initiatives to
transition government faster than private markets. (5) Expand incentives and
reduce market barriers for investments in energy efficiency and
productivity. (6) Incentivize investments
in technology innovation tied to renewable energy and efficiency and
productivity.
The prescriptive set of activities identified above are no
surprise to anyone involved in accelerating our transition to a sustainable
economy. The effort to adopt these steps
has to take place throughout society, to build a groundswell of activity that
is sound and impactful, building up from the local, state and regional levels
to the national and international level.
Significant progress has been made in specific sectors and in specific
countries, such as Denmark with wind, German with Energiewende, and Texas with
wind power. There are many more
examples, including renewable fuels and efficiency, but the pace has to
increase and the efforts have to expand.
Wednesday, November 13, 2013
Japan's Solar Feed-in Tariff (FIT) Worth An Astounding $3.15/watt!
Japan implemented a significantly generous solar feed in tariff, equivalent to $0.42/kWh for 20 years. It is expected that this will result in every available inch of available land being deployed with solar until there is no land available. One innovation is the newly opened 70 MW Kyocera solar plant, which covers 315 acres of land filled in a shallow area off the coast of Japan.
The present value of the solar FIT is equivalent to $3.15/watt, which exceeds the fully loaded installed system price. Hence, we are going to see an unprecedented boom in solar deployment in Japan over the next few years.
Below is Japan's tariff schedule for renewable energy along with several photographs of the Kyocera plant..
The present value of the solar FIT is equivalent to $3.15/watt, which exceeds the fully loaded installed system price. Hence, we are going to see an unprecedented boom in solar deployment in Japan over the next few years.
Below is Japan's tariff schedule for renewable energy along with several photographs of the Kyocera plant..
Monday, November 11, 2013
JAPAN STARTS UP OFFSHORE WIND FARM NEAR FUKUSHIMA
Source: Associated Press
— Nov. 11, 2013 5:27 AM EST
— Nov. 11, 2013 5:27 AM EST
ONAHAMA PORT, Japan (AP) — Japan switched on the first turbine at a wind farm 20 kilometers (12 miles) off the coast of Fukushima on Monday, feeding electricity to the grid tethered to the tsunami-crippled nuclear plant onshore.
The wind farm near the Fukushima Dai-Ichi nuclear power plant is to eventually have a generation capacity of 1 gigawatt from 143 turbines, though its significance is not limited to the energy it will produce. Symbolically, the turbines will help restore the role of energy supplier to a region decimated by a population exodus following the multiple meltdowns triggered by the March 2011 earthquake and tsunami.
"Many people were victimized and hurt by the accident at the Fukushima Dai-Ichi nuclear power plant, so it is very meaningful to have a new source of energy — renewable energy — based here," said Kazuyoshi Akaba, a vice minister of economy, trade and industry, after the turbine was turned on.
"It is the government's mission to ensure this project is a success," he said.
The project also highlights Japan's aspirations to sell its advanced energy technology around the globe.
Trading houses such as Marubeni Corp., which is leading the consortium building the offshore wind farm, are investing aggressively in renewable energy as well as conventional sources, helped by government policies aimed at nurturing favored industries.
All of Japan's 50 viable nuclear reactors are offline for safety checks under new regulatory guidelines drawn up after the Fukushima disaster. Utility companies have applied to restart at least 14 reactors under those new guidelines, which include more stringent requirements for earthquake and tsunami protections, among other precautions.
In Japan, the push to tap more renewable sources to help offset lost power capacity, and reduce costs for imported natural gas and oil, also got a boost last year with the implementation of a higher wholesale tariff for energy generated from non-conventional sources.
Japan, whose coast is mostly ringed by deep waters, is pioneering floating wind turbine construction, required for seabed depths greater than 50 meters (165 feet). The 2 megawatt downwind floating turbine that began operation Monday was built at a dry dock near Tokyo and towed to its location off the northeastern coast. Six huge chains anchor it to the seabed 120 meters (almost 400 feet) below.
The turbine is linked to a 66 kilovolt floating power substation, the world's first according to the project operators, via an extra-high voltage undersea cable.
As the government and Tokyo Electric Power Co. struggle to clean up from the nuclear disaster and begin the decades-long task of decommissioning Fukushima Dai-Ichi, Japan's energy industry is in the midst of a transition whose outcome remains uncertain.
Most leading members of Japan's ruling Liberal Democratic Party and the powerful business lobbies such as Keidanren, and many experts, argue that wind and other renewables alone simply cannot make up for the steady and huge baseload power produced by nuclear plants.
"I favor renewables. But it would be irresponsible to create a pie-in-the-sky claim that renewables alone are the answer," said Paul Scalise, a fellow at Tokyo University and expert on Japan's energy industry. "There is no such thing as a perfect power source."
He cites figures showing wind power's average generating capacity at 2 watts per square meter versus 20 watts per square meter for solar power — and 1,000 watts per square meter for nuclear.
Eventually there could be dozens of wind turbines off Fukushima's scenic but deserted coast. The project is meant to demonstrate the feasibility of locating these towering turbines in offshore regions where the winds are more reliable and there are fewer "not in my backyard" concerns. Bigger turbines that might create noise problems onshore are not an issue so far offshore.
Yuhei Sato, the governor of Fukushima Prefecture who has lobbied hard for support following the 2011 disasters, said he expected local businesses to benefit from the wind farm. A research center is planned for Koriyama, a city further inland, and studies are underway on the impact of local fisheries from the floating turbines.
"We are moving ahead one step at a time. This wind farm is a symbol of our future," Sato said.
In theory, Japan has the potential for 1,600 gigawatts of wind power, most of it offshore. About a dozen projects are already in the works, from Kyushu in the south to Hokkaido in the north.
But wind power can be notoriously unstable: when the switch was pushed to "on" on Monday, the audience of VIP officials watched tensely as the wind turbine's blades, displayed on a video screen at a tourist center onshore, appeared becalmed. Eventually, though, the blades slowly began rotating.
Boeing to Deploy 9 MW of In-River Turbines with RER Hydro in Montreal
Boeing and RER Hydro to Provide Quebec with Clean Hydrokinetic Power
"This agreement between industry and government will deliver renewable power while protecting the environment," said Boeing Defense, Space & Security President and CEO Dennis Muilenburg. "It also builds on Boeing's long-term, strategic partnership with Canada, supporting customers from aerospace and defense to clean energy, generating high-quality jobs, and making a difference in the community."
Imad Hamad, RER’s chief executive officer, added that "Because it’s not a dam, the turbines generate clean power without disrupting the river flow or the natural habitat. Numerous independent studies demonstrate that our technology has no negative impact on fish or other marine life."
This agreement is the first commercial sale of this technology. RER, which has been testing a prototype in the river for more than three years, will build the turbines in its new manufacturing plant here, thus creating the world's first river hydrokinetic manufacturing base in Quebec.
Boeing and RER signed an agreement last year giving Boeing exclusive rights to market and sell the turbines around the world. Boeing is providing program management, engineering, manufacturing, and supplier-management expertise, in addition to servicing the turbines. Boeing currently works with 40 suppliers in Quebec, contributing to the $1 billion in economic revenue Boeing generates annually across Canada.
As a leading developer of ecologically minded hydrokinetic harvesting solutions that preserve free-running rivers and their ecosystems, RER Hydro Ltd. has successfully created a cost-effective and environmentally friendly technology that requires minimum civil works and has no negative ecological impacts. The TREK (Kinetic Energy Recovery Turbine) technology is an innovative, proven solution that allows for the large-scale harnessing of the vast hydrokinetic energy available in rivers across the world.
Contact:
Miriam Djebbar
Agreement marks the 1st commercial sale of hydrokinetic turbines
Source: Boeing Company Press Release

BECANCOUR, Quebec, Nov. 11, 2013 -- Boeing [NYSE: BA] and
its partner RER Hydro of Montreal have entered into a multiyear agreement with
the government of Quebec to provide 40 hydrokinetic turbines that will generate
about 9 megawatts of clean, renewable power.
Once completed, the St. Lawrence River near downtown
Montreal will have the world’s largest river-generated, hydrokinetic turbine
farm.
"This agreement between industry and government will deliver renewable power while protecting the environment," said Boeing Defense, Space & Security President and CEO Dennis Muilenburg. "It also builds on Boeing's long-term, strategic partnership with Canada, supporting customers from aerospace and defense to clean energy, generating high-quality jobs, and making a difference in the community."
Imad Hamad, RER’s chief executive officer, added that "Because it’s not a dam, the turbines generate clean power without disrupting the river flow or the natural habitat. Numerous independent studies demonstrate that our technology has no negative impact on fish or other marine life."
This agreement is the first commercial sale of this technology. RER, which has been testing a prototype in the river for more than three years, will build the turbines in its new manufacturing plant here, thus creating the world's first river hydrokinetic manufacturing base in Quebec.
Boeing and RER signed an agreement last year giving Boeing exclusive rights to market and sell the turbines around the world. Boeing is providing program management, engineering, manufacturing, and supplier-management expertise, in addition to servicing the turbines. Boeing currently works with 40 suppliers in Quebec, contributing to the $1 billion in economic revenue Boeing generates annually across Canada.
As a leading developer of ecologically minded hydrokinetic harvesting solutions that preserve free-running rivers and their ecosystems, RER Hydro Ltd. has successfully created a cost-effective and environmentally friendly technology that requires minimum civil works and has no negative ecological impacts. The TREK (Kinetic Energy Recovery Turbine) technology is an innovative, proven solution that allows for the large-scale harnessing of the vast hydrokinetic energy available in rivers across the world.
A unit of The Boeing Company, Boeing Defense, Space &
Security is one of the world's largest defense, space and security businesses
specializing in innovative and capabilities-driven customer solutions, and the
world's largest and most versatile manufacturer of military aircraft.
Headquartered in St. Louis, Boeing Defense, Space & Security is a $33
billion business with 58,000 employees worldwide. Follow us on Twitter:
@BoeingDefense.
# # #
B-roll video is available to the media through the contacts
below.
Contact:
Robert Sterling
Ventures
Boeing Defense, Space & Security
Office: +1 314-233-1816
Mobile: +1 314-681-3463
robert.sterling2@boeing.com
Miriam Djebbar
RER Hydro
Office: +1 514-685-8735 ext. 7410
Mobile: +1 514-267-4526
miriam.djebbar@rerhydro.comSaturday, November 2, 2013
Energy Prices Have Doubled in 15 Years, Imperilling Future Economic Growth and Prosperity
There are several points to make about energy prices. First, energy prices in the United States, based on all forms of energy at the retail level, reached their peak in 2007, at $22.79/MMBtu. Second, by 2010, energy prices had fallen 13% below the peak, and, in 2013, are heading back up. Prices in the chart below are expressed in inflation adjusted 2011 dollars.
A third point is that overall energy prices track petroleum prices very closely, demonstrating the enduring dominance of petroleum in our economy. Sustained high prices for energy in our economy are impinging on overall economic activity and employment. In 2013, energy prices are nearly twice what they were in the 1990's.
Our energy picture presents a fundamental challenge for the country's long term economic growth and prosperity. As has been presented in earlier blog posts, overall employment in the United States is 98% explained by energy use and petroleum prices. The great recession of 2008 caused a downdraft in employment, with a return to pre-recession levels not likely to take place until 2018.
Petroleum remains a significant force and commanding presence in our economy. Petroleum prices appear to drive overall energy prices in the economy. Our ability as a nation to influence petroleum prices has slipped from our grasp, with emerging countries such as India and China driving up and sustaining high levels of global oil demand. It has also been discovered that Asian countries have a lower elasticity of demand to price compared to developed countries. Asian countries, in other words, are more resilient to high prices than in the United States. The implication is that we are captive to market forces acting on petroleum beyond our control.
In addition to a loss of our ability to influence oil prices to our favor, it appears that we have also entered a new higher energy price plateau that has caused our economic fortunes to dim. Higher energy costs have caused demand to be tempered along with a reduction in economic activity. To sustain the economy requires reducing energy costs, increasing energy use and increasing energy efficiency and productivity.
Creating a more robust, resilient, equitable and sustainable economy can be accomplished, although it won't be without its challenges. To have a growing economy, even at moderate growth rates, requires a combination of low cost energy, increased energy consumption, and continuous improvement in energy efficiency and productivity. To regain control over our economic future, to unshackle ourselves from the vagaries of foreign markets and their associated high demand and high price regime, requires increasing the mix of less volatile and domestic sources of energy.
Petroleum and equivalent liquid energy products constitute approximately 36% of our energy use in the United States. This points to the great utility of petroleum and equivalent liquid fuels, which is difficult to replace or find substitutes. Significant efforts have been expended to produce liquid fuels, including ethanol and other biomass based liquid fuels. These efforts have been challenging due to poor energy balances and high costs. In addition to trying to alternative liquid fuels, significant efforts are underway to increase transportation efficiency with hybrids and other technologies, and introduce alternative fuel vehicles, considering electric cars and hydrogen vehicles. All of these technologies are expensive, may have performance challenges, and can require significant infrastructure investments. Finding a lower cost alternative to petroleum with equal or better utility is one of the most difficult challenges facing our economic future and well being.
The boom in natural gas in the United States has been quite beneficial to the economics of electricity generation and reducing the country's carbon emissions. The cost to produce a kilowatt-hour with natural gas in late 2013 is approximately 30% less than the cost to produce an equivalent kilowatt-hour from coal. This is due principally to the significant increase in natural gas production due to fracking, which in 2013 accounts for approximately 28% of the natural gas supply in the United States. The increase of natural gas supply drove prices down, with coal plants becoming uneconomic as a result.
For electricity production, the United States has shifted towards cleaner lower cost natural gas, and seen relatively significant increases in renewable energy, including wind turbines and solar power. The economics of both wind and solar have improved dramatically over this time period as well, with wind competitive with coal and the solar becoming competitive in extremely large deployments in sunny Western states.
The addition of renewables to the German grid, for example, are wreaking havoc on standard utility economics, in new and unexpected ways. Renewables are capital intensive and have zero fuel (marginal) costs. In a standard utility economic model, wholesale generation prices are set by the marginal cost to produce the last kilowatt hour in each hour. Grid operators dispatch generation resources using a system called economic dispatch, dispatching the lowest cost power plants first. Baseload powre plants have typically been nuclear power plants and coal plants, which had the lowest marginal operating costs and basically ran most of the time. Next up historically, covering the shoulder portion of the demand curve, would have been natural gas power plants.
Historically, heat rates and fuel costs for natural gas plants placed them at an economic disadvantage to coal plants. With the advent of fracking, driving down natural gas costs, and continuous improvement in the efficiency and heat rates of natural gas power plants, especially combined cycle combustion turbines, gas plants are have lower marginal costs than coal plants in the United States. As such, natural gas plants are displacing coal plants in the economic dispatch order in the United States. For several hundred hours per year, when the highest demand occurs, grid operators typically dispatch the highest marginal cost plants, including oil and diesel power plants.
Wholesale generators are compensated for their electricity production applying the marginal rate in each hour to all electricity produced in that hour. Based on historic patterns, this approach has been understood, and investments in generation assets have been based on this economic construct to cover plant fuel, O&M and capital costs. This economic paradigm, in place for decades, however, is going through a radical and disruptive change, with the introduction of non-dispatchable zero marginal cost renewables, and the introduction of demand side / distributed generation resources.
In locations as diverse as Germany and Texas, with independent grids and high penetration of renewable resources, grid economics have been upended. At times, on both grids, negative wholesale pricing was used to discourage power production. This occurred at times when non-dispatchable renewables were operating at full blast, typically a very windy period, and demand for power on the grid was at a low point, typically at night. In addition to negative pricing, grid operators also shut renewable plants down. The effective of negative pricing impacts both renewable and conventional power economics.
In Germany, the low marginal cost of renewable power is being applied as the basis for compensation for conventional power plants. In addition, the operating hours of natural gas plants are being cut back with the increased generation by renewable power. Renewable power plants are given preference on dispatch, to the chagrin of conventional power plants. The earnings of power companies in Germany have been significantly reduced. E.ON AG, for example, is suffering reduced earnings year over year, with a loss reported in the third quarter of 2013. It attributes the losses to poor economic performance of natural gas resources and the priority given to renewable power.
The economic impact of renewable power is disruptive in two ways. First, renewable power plants are allowed to operate when the wind blows and when the sun shines, given preference on operation over other resources. This cuts into the operating hours of standard power plants, reducing their capital cost coverage ratios. The second impact is the reduction in marginal costs applied to conventional power plants. Renewables are shifting marginal costs downward at times which were at once higher cost regimes on the dispatch curve. this is reducing the revenues for conventional power plants, hurting their economics.
The other area of concern to utility companies is the devolvement of customer energy demand associated with expanding distributed generation, increased efficiency and greater demand response, all of which reduce utility revenues. The combination of solar power, fuel cells and improved efficiency reduce the revenues associated with customers that implement energy reduction initiatives. As such, there are fewer kilowatt-hours sold, and fewer kilowatt-hours to spread fixed costs of operating utilities. As a result, utilities have to increase the rates they charge for electricity, to compensate for fewer electrons being sold. The customers that have taken advantage of solar and efficiency incentives, increasing electric rates have less of an impact than those customers that have not improved their efficiency or reduced their load through distributed generation.
As rates go up, and efficiency and distributed generation costs go down, incentives to switch away from the utility increase, and more and more customers will further reduce their electricity purchases from monopoly utilities. In many parts of the United States, utility companies have already had to abandon their generation business, focusing on transmission and distribution. Many utilities are investor owned utilities, with their capital sourced through public capital markets. As their revenue models are called into question, and electric revenues are flat or declining, utilities may hit tipping points, where regulators won't support ever increasing electric rates applied to dissipating electric sales. At that point, investors may run for the exists, destroying the IOU utility compact put in place nearly a century ago. This is getting interesting.
A third point is that overall energy prices track petroleum prices very closely, demonstrating the enduring dominance of petroleum in our economy. Sustained high prices for energy in our economy are impinging on overall economic activity and employment. In 2013, energy prices are nearly twice what they were in the 1990's.
Our energy picture presents a fundamental challenge for the country's long term economic growth and prosperity. As has been presented in earlier blog posts, overall employment in the United States is 98% explained by energy use and petroleum prices. The great recession of 2008 caused a downdraft in employment, with a return to pre-recession levels not likely to take place until 2018.
Petroleum remains a significant force and commanding presence in our economy. Petroleum prices appear to drive overall energy prices in the economy. Our ability as a nation to influence petroleum prices has slipped from our grasp, with emerging countries such as India and China driving up and sustaining high levels of global oil demand. It has also been discovered that Asian countries have a lower elasticity of demand to price compared to developed countries. Asian countries, in other words, are more resilient to high prices than in the United States. The implication is that we are captive to market forces acting on petroleum beyond our control.
In addition to a loss of our ability to influence oil prices to our favor, it appears that we have also entered a new higher energy price plateau that has caused our economic fortunes to dim. Higher energy costs have caused demand to be tempered along with a reduction in economic activity. To sustain the economy requires reducing energy costs, increasing energy use and increasing energy efficiency and productivity.
Creating a more robust, resilient, equitable and sustainable economy can be accomplished, although it won't be without its challenges. To have a growing economy, even at moderate growth rates, requires a combination of low cost energy, increased energy consumption, and continuous improvement in energy efficiency and productivity. To regain control over our economic future, to unshackle ourselves from the vagaries of foreign markets and their associated high demand and high price regime, requires increasing the mix of less volatile and domestic sources of energy.
Petroleum and equivalent liquid energy products constitute approximately 36% of our energy use in the United States. This points to the great utility of petroleum and equivalent liquid fuels, which is difficult to replace or find substitutes. Significant efforts have been expended to produce liquid fuels, including ethanol and other biomass based liquid fuels. These efforts have been challenging due to poor energy balances and high costs. In addition to trying to alternative liquid fuels, significant efforts are underway to increase transportation efficiency with hybrids and other technologies, and introduce alternative fuel vehicles, considering electric cars and hydrogen vehicles. All of these technologies are expensive, may have performance challenges, and can require significant infrastructure investments. Finding a lower cost alternative to petroleum with equal or better utility is one of the most difficult challenges facing our economic future and well being.
The boom in natural gas in the United States has been quite beneficial to the economics of electricity generation and reducing the country's carbon emissions. The cost to produce a kilowatt-hour with natural gas in late 2013 is approximately 30% less than the cost to produce an equivalent kilowatt-hour from coal. This is due principally to the significant increase in natural gas production due to fracking, which in 2013 accounts for approximately 28% of the natural gas supply in the United States. The increase of natural gas supply drove prices down, with coal plants becoming uneconomic as a result.
For electricity production, the United States has shifted towards cleaner lower cost natural gas, and seen relatively significant increases in renewable energy, including wind turbines and solar power. The economics of both wind and solar have improved dramatically over this time period as well, with wind competitive with coal and the solar becoming competitive in extremely large deployments in sunny Western states.
The addition of renewables to the German grid, for example, are wreaking havoc on standard utility economics, in new and unexpected ways. Renewables are capital intensive and have zero fuel (marginal) costs. In a standard utility economic model, wholesale generation prices are set by the marginal cost to produce the last kilowatt hour in each hour. Grid operators dispatch generation resources using a system called economic dispatch, dispatching the lowest cost power plants first. Baseload powre plants have typically been nuclear power plants and coal plants, which had the lowest marginal operating costs and basically ran most of the time. Next up historically, covering the shoulder portion of the demand curve, would have been natural gas power plants.
Historically, heat rates and fuel costs for natural gas plants placed them at an economic disadvantage to coal plants. With the advent of fracking, driving down natural gas costs, and continuous improvement in the efficiency and heat rates of natural gas power plants, especially combined cycle combustion turbines, gas plants are have lower marginal costs than coal plants in the United States. As such, natural gas plants are displacing coal plants in the economic dispatch order in the United States. For several hundred hours per year, when the highest demand occurs, grid operators typically dispatch the highest marginal cost plants, including oil and diesel power plants.
Wholesale generators are compensated for their electricity production applying the marginal rate in each hour to all electricity produced in that hour. Based on historic patterns, this approach has been understood, and investments in generation assets have been based on this economic construct to cover plant fuel, O&M and capital costs. This economic paradigm, in place for decades, however, is going through a radical and disruptive change, with the introduction of non-dispatchable zero marginal cost renewables, and the introduction of demand side / distributed generation resources.
In locations as diverse as Germany and Texas, with independent grids and high penetration of renewable resources, grid economics have been upended. At times, on both grids, negative wholesale pricing was used to discourage power production. This occurred at times when non-dispatchable renewables were operating at full blast, typically a very windy period, and demand for power on the grid was at a low point, typically at night. In addition to negative pricing, grid operators also shut renewable plants down. The effective of negative pricing impacts both renewable and conventional power economics.
In Germany, the low marginal cost of renewable power is being applied as the basis for compensation for conventional power plants. In addition, the operating hours of natural gas plants are being cut back with the increased generation by renewable power. Renewable power plants are given preference on dispatch, to the chagrin of conventional power plants. The earnings of power companies in Germany have been significantly reduced. E.ON AG, for example, is suffering reduced earnings year over year, with a loss reported in the third quarter of 2013. It attributes the losses to poor economic performance of natural gas resources and the priority given to renewable power.
The economic impact of renewable power is disruptive in two ways. First, renewable power plants are allowed to operate when the wind blows and when the sun shines, given preference on operation over other resources. This cuts into the operating hours of standard power plants, reducing their capital cost coverage ratios. The second impact is the reduction in marginal costs applied to conventional power plants. Renewables are shifting marginal costs downward at times which were at once higher cost regimes on the dispatch curve. this is reducing the revenues for conventional power plants, hurting their economics.
The other area of concern to utility companies is the devolvement of customer energy demand associated with expanding distributed generation, increased efficiency and greater demand response, all of which reduce utility revenues. The combination of solar power, fuel cells and improved efficiency reduce the revenues associated with customers that implement energy reduction initiatives. As such, there are fewer kilowatt-hours sold, and fewer kilowatt-hours to spread fixed costs of operating utilities. As a result, utilities have to increase the rates they charge for electricity, to compensate for fewer electrons being sold. The customers that have taken advantage of solar and efficiency incentives, increasing electric rates have less of an impact than those customers that have not improved their efficiency or reduced their load through distributed generation.
As rates go up, and efficiency and distributed generation costs go down, incentives to switch away from the utility increase, and more and more customers will further reduce their electricity purchases from monopoly utilities. In many parts of the United States, utility companies have already had to abandon their generation business, focusing on transmission and distribution. Many utilities are investor owned utilities, with their capital sourced through public capital markets. As their revenue models are called into question, and electric revenues are flat or declining, utilities may hit tipping points, where regulators won't support ever increasing electric rates applied to dissipating electric sales. At that point, investors may run for the exists, destroying the IOU utility compact put in place nearly a century ago. This is getting interesting.
Sunday, October 27, 2013
Whither Inflation? "Many Now Think Inflation Helps"
The New York Times reported on October 27, 2013, that "there is a growing concern inside and outside the Fed that inflation is not rising fast enough." On one level, this apparent policy pivot on the part of the Fed is surprising, given the Fed's long held and overarching aversion to any snippet of inflation in the economy. A second surprise is the idea that increasing inflation is a monetary policy tool available to our government to encourage economic growth. Third, it is also surprising that the Fed is considering inflation as an input into the economy, as opposed to a measure a a result of other economic forces.
In 1966, Alan Greenspan, a recent Chairman of the Federal Reserve, contributed to Ayn Rand's newsletter "Objectivist", writing "In the absence of the gold standard, there is no way to protect savings from confiscation through inflation." In his 18 years at the helm of the Fed, Greenspan's policies were on the side of an inflation hawk. Equally, although in a much different time, Paul Volcker was serenely focused on monetary supply and keeping inflation in check. One of his major efforts as Chairman of the Fed was the taming of the high inflation experienced in the early 1980's, triggering a recession to cool economic activity.
Volcker has also expressed his opinion in the past few years, expressing his concerns over potentially inflationary Fed policies. In November, 2010, he spoke in Singapore about his concerns over the potential emergence of inflation associated with quantitative easing policies being led by Ben Bernanke.
In 2011, Volcker wrote an Op-Ed in the New York Times, further expanding on his concerns about reduced vigilance against inflation on the part of the Federal Reserve and the Obama administration. He also recognized, however, the "desperation" that essentially all the fiscal and monetary tools have been exausted to no great effect, other than saving the economy from going off a cliff, but not leading to even a moderately robust recovery, writing:
"There is great and understandable disappointment about high unemployment and the absence of a robust economy, and even concern about the possibility of a renewed downturn. There is also a sense of desperation that both monetary and fiscal policy have almost exhausted their potential, given the size of the fiscal deficits and the already extremely low level of interest rates."
"Rather, the danger is that if, in desperation, we turn to deliberately seeking inflation to solve real problems — our economic imbalances, sluggish productivity, and excessive leverage — we would soon find that a little inflation doesn’t work."
Our current economic circumstance in the United States is quite troubling, with millions out of work, and job creation and incomes at levels abysmally short of prior levels and what people need and expect. The Obama administration did a remarkable job addressing the great recession, keeping the global economy and financial system from collectively going over the credit cliff. As it is, we are remain reeling from the effects of severe credit correction, with a economy wide shoring up of balance sheets, with all the concomitant reduction in credit availability. There are, however, more pernicious and troubling undercurrents which are slowly and inexorably sinking developed economies below the surface.
The undercurrents to which I refer are the sources of value within the economy, sources of value which have in the past ten years shifted away from the United States economy. Since 1980, there has been a 40% reduction in the number of manufacturing jobs in the United States, one symptom of intense price pressures associated with globalization. The increased cost of many commodities, including oil, leading up to the 2008 great recession, all contributed to putting economic pressures throughout the economy, from households to businesses. Strangely, oil prices did pull back after the 2007 peak, but did rebound back up to over $100 per barrel in 2011.
The normal factors which drive inflation up have not been working their magic in recent years. Wages have been stagnant and demand for goods and services has not strengthened since the recession. Outsourcing manufacturing to other countries along with intense price competition across the economy, with underutilized capacity, has resulted in a price driven recovery, instead of demand driven. Demand is just not rebounding.
On the credit side, interest rates have been extremely low, and the Fed has been injecting funds into the banking system through quantitative easing. Normally, this vast injection of liquidity into the economy would result in a lowering of the barriers to making investments, essentially a lowering of the hurdle rates for capital allocation,which presumably would increase the aggregate number of capital projects approved. If, however, there is no demand for goods and services, there is no fundamental reason for expanding capital projects. In addition to the lack of fundamental demand, banks have increased their credit requirements, and have been shoring up their own balance sheets, with increased capital reserves, reducing risk exposure, and writing down and jettisoning under performing portions of their loan portfolios. In the housing market, there has been a rebound of prices and sales of existing homes. This rebound has resulted in increased prices for housing stock but has not caused an up swell in the prices for labor and materials associated with new construction.
In classical terms, the definition of the cause of inflation is when too many dollars are chasing too few goods and services. This infers that the extent of the Fed's policies on lowering interest rates and providing liquidity to the banking system through the succession of quantitative easing, would normally of resulted in increased inflation. In looking at inflation in the last 40 years, there is a very high correlation between United States inflation levels and the inflation adjusted price of crude oil, as seen in the chart below.

In every period of inflation, there occurs an increase in the price of oil. Accordingly, it is an exogenous factor, oil pricing, that influences inflation. In 2013, the price of oil was above $100 per barrel for most of the year. Also in 2013, the global economy, especially in North America, Europe and emerging economies in Africa and South America have experienced lower growth rates than in 2011 and 2012. The United States is looking at a GDP growth rate for 2013 of 1.5%, significantly lower than the 2.8% in 2012. This reduced growth in the global and United States economy is putting downward pressure on oil demand and oil prices.
Because of this downward pressure on oil demand and prices, we are not likely going to see a rebound of oil prices until 2015, after oil prices have dipped below $60 per barrel and two things happen: (1) the global economy perks back up, and (2) investment in oil drilling pulls back. These two factors lead to a demand resurgence at the same time there has been a pull back in the more expensive drilling activities, which will result in a run up in oil prices. At that time, in 2015, there will be a resurgence of inflation in the United States, and not before.
Caveat - there is a good chance that oil prices will continue to buoyed by global demand factors, given that the Asian economies have lower elasticity of demand to price than European and North American economies. As such, there are likely to retain higher demand for oil in a variety of oil price regimes. This may mean that the global economy is not as whipsawed as it has been in the past with oil demand and price swings creating global economic instability, and less likely cause of a resurgence in inflation in 2015.
Another perspective on the the impact of oil prices on our economy is to look at the relationship between oil price movements and the value of the dollar. The basic premise of the analysis in this blog is that oil is an underlying factor, driving economic activity, influencing inflation and the value of the dollar. The opposite perspective would carry if oil prices were lower, there had been a pull back in oil drilling activity, and there was an up swelling in global economic activity. None of these conditions is true today, as such, we are not going to see a resurgence of inflation until 2015 at the earliest.
In 1966, Alan Greenspan, a recent Chairman of the Federal Reserve, contributed to Ayn Rand's newsletter "Objectivist", writing "In the absence of the gold standard, there is no way to protect savings from confiscation through inflation." In his 18 years at the helm of the Fed, Greenspan's policies were on the side of an inflation hawk. Equally, although in a much different time, Paul Volcker was serenely focused on monetary supply and keeping inflation in check. One of his major efforts as Chairman of the Fed was the taming of the high inflation experienced in the early 1980's, triggering a recession to cool economic activity.
Volcker has also expressed his opinion in the past few years, expressing his concerns over potentially inflationary Fed policies. In November, 2010, he spoke in Singapore about his concerns over the potential emergence of inflation associated with quantitative easing policies being led by Ben Bernanke.
In 2011, Volcker wrote an Op-Ed in the New York Times, further expanding on his concerns about reduced vigilance against inflation on the part of the Federal Reserve and the Obama administration. He also recognized, however, the "desperation" that essentially all the fiscal and monetary tools have been exausted to no great effect, other than saving the economy from going off a cliff, but not leading to even a moderately robust recovery, writing:
"There is great and understandable disappointment about high unemployment and the absence of a robust economy, and even concern about the possibility of a renewed downturn. There is also a sense of desperation that both monetary and fiscal policy have almost exhausted their potential, given the size of the fiscal deficits and the already extremely low level of interest rates."
"Rather, the danger is that if, in desperation, we turn to deliberately seeking inflation to solve real problems — our economic imbalances, sluggish productivity, and excessive leverage — we would soon find that a little inflation doesn’t work."
Our current economic circumstance in the United States is quite troubling, with millions out of work, and job creation and incomes at levels abysmally short of prior levels and what people need and expect. The Obama administration did a remarkable job addressing the great recession, keeping the global economy and financial system from collectively going over the credit cliff. As it is, we are remain reeling from the effects of severe credit correction, with a economy wide shoring up of balance sheets, with all the concomitant reduction in credit availability. There are, however, more pernicious and troubling undercurrents which are slowly and inexorably sinking developed economies below the surface.
The undercurrents to which I refer are the sources of value within the economy, sources of value which have in the past ten years shifted away from the United States economy. Since 1980, there has been a 40% reduction in the number of manufacturing jobs in the United States, one symptom of intense price pressures associated with globalization. The increased cost of many commodities, including oil, leading up to the 2008 great recession, all contributed to putting economic pressures throughout the economy, from households to businesses. Strangely, oil prices did pull back after the 2007 peak, but did rebound back up to over $100 per barrel in 2011.
The normal factors which drive inflation up have not been working their magic in recent years. Wages have been stagnant and demand for goods and services has not strengthened since the recession. Outsourcing manufacturing to other countries along with intense price competition across the economy, with underutilized capacity, has resulted in a price driven recovery, instead of demand driven. Demand is just not rebounding.
On the credit side, interest rates have been extremely low, and the Fed has been injecting funds into the banking system through quantitative easing. Normally, this vast injection of liquidity into the economy would result in a lowering of the barriers to making investments, essentially a lowering of the hurdle rates for capital allocation,which presumably would increase the aggregate number of capital projects approved. If, however, there is no demand for goods and services, there is no fundamental reason for expanding capital projects. In addition to the lack of fundamental demand, banks have increased their credit requirements, and have been shoring up their own balance sheets, with increased capital reserves, reducing risk exposure, and writing down and jettisoning under performing portions of their loan portfolios. In the housing market, there has been a rebound of prices and sales of existing homes. This rebound has resulted in increased prices for housing stock but has not caused an up swell in the prices for labor and materials associated with new construction.
In classical terms, the definition of the cause of inflation is when too many dollars are chasing too few goods and services. This infers that the extent of the Fed's policies on lowering interest rates and providing liquidity to the banking system through the succession of quantitative easing, would normally of resulted in increased inflation. In looking at inflation in the last 40 years, there is a very high correlation between United States inflation levels and the inflation adjusted price of crude oil, as seen in the chart below.

In every period of inflation, there occurs an increase in the price of oil. Accordingly, it is an exogenous factor, oil pricing, that influences inflation. In 2013, the price of oil was above $100 per barrel for most of the year. Also in 2013, the global economy, especially in North America, Europe and emerging economies in Africa and South America have experienced lower growth rates than in 2011 and 2012. The United States is looking at a GDP growth rate for 2013 of 1.5%, significantly lower than the 2.8% in 2012. This reduced growth in the global and United States economy is putting downward pressure on oil demand and oil prices.
Because of this downward pressure on oil demand and prices, we are not likely going to see a rebound of oil prices until 2015, after oil prices have dipped below $60 per barrel and two things happen: (1) the global economy perks back up, and (2) investment in oil drilling pulls back. These two factors lead to a demand resurgence at the same time there has been a pull back in the more expensive drilling activities, which will result in a run up in oil prices. At that time, in 2015, there will be a resurgence of inflation in the United States, and not before.
Caveat - there is a good chance that oil prices will continue to buoyed by global demand factors, given that the Asian economies have lower elasticity of demand to price than European and North American economies. As such, there are likely to retain higher demand for oil in a variety of oil price regimes. This may mean that the global economy is not as whipsawed as it has been in the past with oil demand and price swings creating global economic instability, and less likely cause of a resurgence in inflation in 2015.
Another perspective on the the impact of oil prices on our economy is to look at the relationship between oil price movements and the value of the dollar. The basic premise of the analysis in this blog is that oil is an underlying factor, driving economic activity, influencing inflation and the value of the dollar. The opposite perspective would carry if oil prices were lower, there had been a pull back in oil drilling activity, and there was an up swelling in global economic activity. None of these conditions is true today, as such, we are not going to see a resurgence of inflation until 2015 at the earliest.
Saturday, October 26, 2013
Predicting Employment - US Employment Will Not Achieve Pre-Recession Levels Until 2018
98% of annual employment in the United States in the past 30 years is explained by two factors: total US primary energy use in Btu's and crude oil prices in 2011 dollars per barrel. To predict US employment going forward is simply a matter of forecasting total energy use and inflation adjusted petroleum prices. I say simply almost as tongue in cheek, given uncertainties associated with predicting petroleum prices and energy consumption. This approach does, however, begin to bracket the question.
The initial premise was to take a look at the correlation of aggregate energy consumption and employment. The following chart shows that there is an amazing correlation between employment and energy use in the United States. The energy consumption is based on primary energy use int he United States, expressed in quadrillion Btu's, including all forms of energy. Certain observations can be drawn from the chart. Over the period from around 1955 through 1971, energy use in the United States grew quite rapidly, and grew faster than employment. The impact of the Arab oil embargo can be observed with a downdraft in aggregate energy, followed by another rise and steep drop in 1979. Both of these drops in demand were a result of steep rises in oil prices.
Since 1981, the movements of energy use and employment moved much more in lockstep, with an almost uncanny correlation in the period of 2007 through 2011.
Another observation that appears uncanny is that both energy and employment tripled in the period from 1949 through 2011. Energy use rose from 32 quads in 1949 to 97 quads in 2011. Employment rose from 44 million in 1949 to 131 million in 2011.
The most troubling observation about this data is that our energy use as a nation appears to have stopped moving upward, hitting a peak of 101.3 quadrillion Btu's in 2007, with 2013 primary energy use around 97 quads, or 4% below the 2007 peak. At a very basic level, we may not achieve pre-recession employment levels until such time that energy use has moved up by 5%. Indeed, the trajectory of growth in primary energy consumption has stagnated since 2000, with current energy use of around 97 quads below the 2000 level of 98.8 quads. As such, the inference is that we may have hit a new period in the US economy, with low growth in energy consumption, with a corresponding period of low growth in employment.
To further my understanding of the relationship between energy and employment, I performed a regression analysis of US employment from 1982 through 2011 expressed in millions, against primary energy consumption in quadrillion Btu's, and inflation adjusted crude oil prices expressed in constant 2011 dollars per barrel. I arrived at an equation which explains 98% of employment levels in the United States. I applied the equation first to historical energy use and oil price data, to see how it fit with actual employment levels in the past 30 years. I then applied the equation to develop a forecast of employment, based on EIA's forecast primary energy use, and fixing crude oil prices at $96 per barrel in 2011 dollars. The results of these analyses can be seen in the chart below.
Based on EIA's forecast of primary energy use, the regression analysis tells us that employment levels in the United States will not achieve pre-recession levels until 2018.
The data also tells us that employment is going to grow by 0.4% per year over the next 20 years. Unless something changes drastically, this means that the people of the United States will be suffering extended underemployment for decades to come.
The initial premise was to take a look at the correlation of aggregate energy consumption and employment. The following chart shows that there is an amazing correlation between employment and energy use in the United States. The energy consumption is based on primary energy use int he United States, expressed in quadrillion Btu's, including all forms of energy. Certain observations can be drawn from the chart. Over the period from around 1955 through 1971, energy use in the United States grew quite rapidly, and grew faster than employment. The impact of the Arab oil embargo can be observed with a downdraft in aggregate energy, followed by another rise and steep drop in 1979. Both of these drops in demand were a result of steep rises in oil prices.
Since 1981, the movements of energy use and employment moved much more in lockstep, with an almost uncanny correlation in the period of 2007 through 2011. Another observation that appears uncanny is that both energy and employment tripled in the period from 1949 through 2011. Energy use rose from 32 quads in 1949 to 97 quads in 2011. Employment rose from 44 million in 1949 to 131 million in 2011.
The most troubling observation about this data is that our energy use as a nation appears to have stopped moving upward, hitting a peak of 101.3 quadrillion Btu's in 2007, with 2013 primary energy use around 97 quads, or 4% below the 2007 peak. At a very basic level, we may not achieve pre-recession employment levels until such time that energy use has moved up by 5%. Indeed, the trajectory of growth in primary energy consumption has stagnated since 2000, with current energy use of around 97 quads below the 2000 level of 98.8 quads. As such, the inference is that we may have hit a new period in the US economy, with low growth in energy consumption, with a corresponding period of low growth in employment.
To further my understanding of the relationship between energy and employment, I performed a regression analysis of US employment from 1982 through 2011 expressed in millions, against primary energy consumption in quadrillion Btu's, and inflation adjusted crude oil prices expressed in constant 2011 dollars per barrel. I arrived at an equation which explains 98% of employment levels in the United States. I applied the equation first to historical energy use and oil price data, to see how it fit with actual employment levels in the past 30 years. I then applied the equation to develop a forecast of employment, based on EIA's forecast primary energy use, and fixing crude oil prices at $96 per barrel in 2011 dollars. The results of these analyses can be seen in the chart below.
Based on EIA's forecast of primary energy use, the regression analysis tells us that employment levels in the United States will not achieve pre-recession levels until 2018.
The data also tells us that employment is going to grow by 0.4% per year over the next 20 years. Unless something changes drastically, this means that the people of the United States will be suffering extended underemployment for decades to come.
Wednesday, October 23, 2013
Carbon Tax: A Few Thoughts on Implications for Economic Growth and Clean Energy Investment Policies
(Written in response to article on thebreakthrough.org site: "Should We Swap Energy Subsidies for a Carbon Tax?")
A carbon tax will impact the economy, with the directionality and extent conditional upon alternatives available to energy consumers, and the allocation of carbon tax receipts by the government. In addition, increased taxation reduces the velocity of money in the economy, which reduces economic activity.
The impact of a carbon tax on energy consumers depends on available alternatives and opportunities for switching. In the short term, a carbon tax would have a negative effect on the economy, diverting financial resources away from household budgets, reducing discretionary spending, and reducing profits for businesses. The effect of a tax on gasoline for consumers, for example, results in reduced driving, or reducing other expenditures. Wealthy consumers can offset increased gasoline costs by purchasing a hybrid car, overcoming the increase in gasoline taxes.
Over time, leveraging market forces to identify and source lower carbon alternatives can be the most effective means to obtain the greatest return on deployed capital and resources. If there are no lower cost forms of energy available, or capital for improving efficiency is limited, then the overall effect of a carbon tax will be reduced economic activity.
A carbon tax is regressive, as economically disadvantaged people do not have the capital and resources to acquire lower cost alternatives, resulting in their otherwise being stuck with a higher cost life. This points to the need for the government to dampen the negative impacts of the carbon tax.
The choice of what the government does with carbon tax receipts is critical, informed by the potential economic pratfalls associated with instituting the carbon tax. Overcoming the dampening effect of a carbon tax is accomplished by making lower cost energy resources available as well as loosening up capital resources to accelerate investments in improving energy efficiency and productivity. A 5% carbon tax, for example, can be overcome by a 7% improvement in energy efficiency, for example, with the added 2% to cover capital costs.
A 5% carbon tax may encourage certain switching behaviors, but as an incentive, is not sufficient to encourage investment in alternative energy technologies that have larger price/performance gaps. For example, there was a time when wind turbines were three times more expansive than what is needed to compete on the grid. A 5% carbon tax would really not be enough to encourage investment to bridge a 200% price/performance. Hence, there is a reason for governments to participate implement policies targeting closing the price/performance gap on emerging clean energy technologies. Wind and solar technologies, for example, have both benefited from favorable financial policies on the part of governments. As such, in certain markets around the world, both wind and solar power technologies are achieving grid parity economies. These cost reductions have been achieved by the government priming market demand, resulting in scale economies and continuous movement down the learning curve.
In summary, it is not a question of swapping energy subsidies for a carbon tax. It is recommended to have both policies, with receipts from a carbon tax providing energy subsidies to encourage lower cost alternatives, encouragement of investments in energy efficiency and productivity, as well as addressing regressive nature of the tax.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






